Jayden Scott Bendetti, a young, humble, and shy-by-nature high school senior, wrestling athlete, and academic achiever from Manchester, Vermont, who just turned eighteen and lives alone with his father, has a big secret. Among other things, he is the most handsome guy in school, with every girl swooning over him and even some boys. As he comes of age, Jayden finds himself questioning his evolving feelings for his best friend, Ethan, the charismatic captain of the wrestling team. However, Ethan's heart is already taken, and he is in a long-term, committed relationship with his girlfriend. As a result, Jayden, who has a healthy sex drive, turns to dating apps, where he meets Jason, a sexy hockey player from a neighboring town, with whom the physical attraction is undeniable, and Nick18, a discreet and mysterious guy, with whom he develops a deep connection. But are Jason and Nick18 really who Jayden thinks they are, or are they hiding their true selves?