The Punic Wars

by Adrian Goldsworthy

Book Overview

.""a masterful account that will appeal to both specialists and general readers who appreciate a superbly told story.explains complicated military moves in easily understood language.portraits of some... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0304352845
• ISBN13: 9780304352845
• Release Date: June 2001
• Publisher: Cassell
• Length: 416 Pages
• Weight: 1.00 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.7" x 6.3" x 9.6"

Customer Reviews

My new source for Punic War!

Fantastic book. Well written and easy to follow. This book will stay as my reference for Punic wars. Though i liked more the previous title "The punic Wars". ;)

Invigorating and modern

Definitely a great read. Despite the fallacious pitch on the back "The cast of endlessly fascinating characters includes the generals Hannibal and Scipio, as well as treacherous chieftains, beautiful princesses, scheming politicians, and tough professional warriors.", a great and entertaining read. Almost reads like a novel, while still solidly argumented and avoiding the easy melodrama. Battles of the Antiquity are depicted in detail, consideing logistics and actual hand-to-hand fighting. Also an analysis that goes beyond the facts to understand social and political conditions. Sources are compared, decisions are dicussed, plausible explanations are proposed, but the author always manages not to appear as the pedant know-it-all but as a modern teacher who challenges the reader, and offers various reasons for enigmatic political or strategic decisions. A highly entertaining and intellectually refreshing read, thank you Mr Goldsworthy. I will investigate your other books.

Accessible, useful, great

One of the most confusing dramas throughout human history is the Second Punic War; the nature of the First and Third, although more easily understood, simply add to this confusion. Adrian Goldsworthy has put together a narrative history that easily solves this problem. The story he presents is clear, concise, and devoid of an overemphasis on unfamiliar names.This single-volume history of all three conflicts is clearly the best out there. Goldsworthy does an excellent job of neutrally explaining the cuases of all three (difficult to do, as all the sources are Roman). The conflict is expertly explained without getting bogged down in the details of too many individual battles. Strategy and tactics are explained as resulting from the technology and culture of the time in a way that is both informative and interesting.One of the best aspects of this book is that it is filled with maps, and that they are placed in the book at the precise moment when you need to consult one. This is so rare in contemporary writing that praise for this should be counted doubly.The one detractor of the book is that it is lacking in illustrations. Naval and siege technologies are described in some detail, yet very few complimentary illustrations or diagrams are offered. However, I'll (and I assume you will too) take the maps over the illustrations any day.Essentially, this is the finest book on the subject, and is highly recommended for readers of all historical interests...

All Three Punic Wars for the Price of One!

Mr. Goldsworthy presents a clean and concise analysis of the three Punic Wars which beset Rome and Carthage in the 3rd and 2nd centuries BC. There is not much to quibble about with this book, presenting as it does one of the best studies of all there conflicts out there. The author discusses the primary works of Polybius, Appian, Livy and others and lists their strong and weak points in describing the Punic conflict. What the book lacks if anything is a few illustrations showing the reader what some of the naval vessels of the period looked like. The detailed descriptions provided of their construction and use is not supported by any pictures. Otherwise, the narrative flows smoothly, with the author commenting on the validity of the principal primary works and attempting to fill in the gaps with his own astute ideas. Obviously the information on the 2nd Punic War with Hannibal's epic invasion of Rome is the most completely covered. The author provides a great blow by blow description of the early campaigns in Italy from Hannibal's first success at the Trebbia River to Cannae itself. Our information on the 1st and 3rd Punic Wars is much less complete and therefor receives correspondlingly less attention. The author is careful not to compare the military genius of Hannibal and Scipio Africanus, believing that such comparisons are poinless, even if fun for the military historian. Goldsworthy tries to fill in the numerous gaps left by the primary sources with his own hypothesis which allows the reader to make his own conclusions. This book provides fresh analysis of an age-old conflcit often seen to this day with many myths. The author provides comparisons with the past to the present with the military situation which might be annoying to the pure student of antiquity, but which is useful to the military historian. The main strength of this work is that it provides a comprehensive and comparative account of the all three of the Punic conflicts. The author carefully traces the strategies both combatants took, and notes their differences in each conflict. A most excellent read and a must for military historians and those fascinated with antiquity and early Rome.

Excellent History

"DELENDA EST CARTHAGO" "Carthage Must be Destroyed" those most famous words were spoken by Marcus Porcius Cato in the 2nd Century BC. In this new book on the Punic Wars by Adrian Goldsworthy we are taken back into this most fascinating period of history. We follow in the steps of Hannibal, Hasdrubal, Hamilcar, Scipio Africanus and many more famous and infamous commanders and leaders as the Roman Legions and the soldiers and sailors of Carthage clash in this gigantic struggle of the Ancient World.Each of the three wars are described in as much detail as possible bearing in mind the lack of primary sources for some periods. We follow the stalemate in Sicily during the First Punic War (264-241 BC). Then the more famous struggle in Spain and Italy during the Second Punic War (218-202 BC), followed by the final Roman victory in the Third Punic War (149-146 BC).The author provides details of all the famous battles, Trebia, Lake Trasimene, Cannae and of course Zama. He also follows the lesser-known campaigns in Spain, Macedonia and Sicily. I found the author to be very fair in his assessment of the commanders and their decisions and offers comments on the sources used in his book and others.I would compare this book favourably with Nigel Bagnall's `Punic Wars' and both books sit proudly in my library. The author took the time to explain the military traditions, training and tactics of the two opponents, which assisted greatly when it came to follow the battles. 16 maps are provided to assist in the narrative and all where of a decent standard however, no illustrations were to be found in the book.The book was easy to read and the narrative flowed along faultlessly. Overall this is a very decent one-volume account of the Punic Wars and I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys decent history or who has a love for this period.