When the students of OLPH Catholic School prepare to perform the Passion Play for their parish, no one expects the performance to become a battleground. But when the mother of the boy portraying Jesus suddenly interrupts the play and reveals that her son is Jewish, Sister Mary Joseph -- living in disguise as the parish priest -- must confront a controversy that pits religious tradition against the simple command to love one's neighbor, while risking everything to follow the calling she believes God has given her. In this thought-provoking continuation of the Hail Mary series, Sister Mary Joseph faces a growing crisis that threatens both her parish and the secret she has worked so hard to protect.