I have dedicated my career to the study of numismatics, consistently verifying definitions and information with reputable sources. Through this rigorous process, I have identified that many books inaccurately describe error coin definitions, minting procedures, and the root causes of errors and variations. When encountering information, I believe to be incorrect, I cross-reference it with credible numismatic resources to confirm accuracy, even if I am already familiar with the correct answer.
Since 2024, I have reviewed 60 books, 55 of which lack credibility. My review process focuses on books achieving an Amazon Best Seller Rank (BSR) below 100,000. Additionally, I examine books with rankings above 100,000 that raise suspicion, assessing them for plagiarism and potential alias connections.
Blake AlmaJustin Couch Ken Potter & Brian Allen Sam Sommer Stan McDonald I have successfully facilitated the removal of 20 books from Amazon due to plagiarism.
Many individuals, likely unfamiliar with coin collecting, are susceptible to deceptive content. These readers often leave five-star reviews for books containing inaccuracies and misleading information.
The primary issues with five-star reviewers include:
- Limited knowledge of coin collecting.
- Acceptance of content as accurate without verification.
- Potential affiliations with or incentives from the author.
The authors of these questionable books often fall into the following categories:
- Young individuals misrepresent themselves as experienced collectors
- Foreign entities posing as American authors.
- Plagiarists who appropriate content from reputable numismatic sources.
- Inexperienced writers are exploiting Amazon's lenient publishing policies for profit.
Many books examined in this review appear to be authored by deceptive entities, potentially hackers, based on the following observations:
- Use of non-standard U.S. terminology, such as "flan" or "blending."
- Paragraphs that seem AI-generated are characterized by yet nonsensical sentences.
- Glossaries containing peculiar entries, such as "zone lines."
- Author photos verified as AI-generated or sourced from the internet, often depicting outdated attire, like tweed jackets, inconsistent with the current era.
- Multiple books published by a single individual using various aliases, accompanied by fabricated biographies and photographs.
- Claims of prominence or affiliation with nonexistent coin organizations.
- Easily identifiable errors and inaccuracies, such as referencing a nonexistent rare 1966-D Lincoln cent.