A Life of Jung

By Ronald Hayman and Robert L. Jr. Hayman

Book Overview

It seems Jung is usually seen as an idol or is condemned for his failings. Ronald Hayman neither ignores Jung's faults nor exaggerates them. Using a substantial amount of unpublished material Hayman... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0393019675
• ISBN13: 9780393019674
• Release Date: January 2001
• Publisher: W W Norton & Co Inc
• Length: 522 Pages
• Weight: 2.07 lbs.
• Dimensions: 6.5" x 2.0" x 10.0"

Customer Reviews

A Masterful Portrait of a Mystical Psychologist

"If it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, we have at least to consider the possibility that we have a small aquatic bird of the family anatidae on our hands."--Douglas Noel Adams (1952 -2001)The Swiss psychiatrist Carl Gustav Jung (1875-1961) was the founder of analytical psychology ("synthetical" psychology seems more appropriate to me).Hating to be called a mystic, Jung became infuriated whenever he was accused of mysticism and claimed that his work was strictlyscientific--based on objective data and empirical fact. But, as Douglas Adams put it, "If it looks like a duck . . ."Jung wrote his doctoral thesis on seances! He was deeply immersed in astrology, spiritualism, mythology, parapsychology, alchemy, Gnosticism, theosophy, clairvoyance, precognition, telepathy, extrasensory perception, reincarnation, UFOs, flying saucers, and various and sundry other occult ideas and practices. Whereas Sigmund Freud was a rationalist and a reductionist, Jung was an idealist and an "expansionist." Fascinated with spiritualism, he sought to unite the wisdom of the East and the West. One wonders if he excluded anything, however far-fetched and ridiculous, from his cosmos. With Jung, all things are possible.As I read Ronald Hayman's masterful biography, I thought of the words of Festus (which could well describe Jung): "Paul! Paul! You are out of your mind! Too much learning has driven you insane! Stark raving mad!" (Acts 26:24).I can imagine this pointed exchange: Jung: "There are MORE things in heaven and earth, Herr Doktor Freud, than are dreamt of in your psychology." Freud: "There are LESS things in heaven and earth, Herr Doktor Jung, than are dreamt of in your psychology."Jung professed to be a Christian, but his religion was unorthodox. He believed that God needed man to correct his (God's) deficiencies, and that Satan was Jesus' older brother. He often spoke heretically of "the dark side of God." Jung confessed that he often wrote ambiguously because truth is too complex to be captured in a non-ambiguous statement. No wonder that Hayman (and this reviewer) finds Jung's work to be vague, nebulous, muddled,confused, and confusing.Hermann Hesse, author of DEMIAN, SIDDHARTHA, and STEPPENWOLF, said, "I have always respected Jung, nevertheless have never been as impressed by his writings as by Freud's." Although I have strong reservations about Freud's "fixed idea" of sexuality, I agree with Hesse. A voracious reader and a scholar of vast erudition, Jung so bubbled over with various (and weird) ideas that his pronouncements became jumbled in a mish-mash of mystical mutterings. His saner ideas dealt with the importance of symbolism, archetypes, personality types (including introverts and extraverts), and the collective unconscious. Like Freud, Jung was charismatic, narcissistic, and authoritarian. Although married to Emilie Preiswerk for 52 years, a devoted wife who bore him five children, Jung drew women "like bees to honey." Quite th

Highly recommended

Many books about Jung are writen by devotees who skip the human aspect of the man. This new and detailed biography of Carl Jung, neither demonizes him, nor elevates him to the status of demi-god, but seeks to reveal the man behind the theory. Jung was a facinating thinker, and revolutionized psycotherapy from the dark and limiting pessimism of Freud. Hayman creates a wonderful biography, rich in insight, and speculation, of the man and his times. Jung's beliefs are often controversial, and frequently misunderstood. Hayman presents a balanced and valued biograph of Jung, faults and all. A wonderful read and a delight to own!