Rebecca has never had to choose her own life. Josie has nothing left to inherit.
When sixteen-year-old Josie Brooks loses both parents in a single terrible night, she's sent to live with grandparents, on a farm at the edge of an Amish community in rural Indiana. She isn't looking for anything except a way to get through the days.
Then an Amish girl her own age starts showing up every Tuesday morning with a crate of eggs - and asking the kind of questions nobody else has thought to ask. Rebecca Weaver has grown up certain of everything: her family, her faith, the shape her whole life is supposed to take. She's never had a reason to wonder whether she actually wants it - until Josie's friendship holds up a mirror she can't quite look away from.