Compact Discs Yearbook 1997-1998, the Penguin Guide to

by Robert Layton, Edward Greenfield, Ivan March

Book Overview

Updated annually, the guide includes for the first time the Editor's Choice of the best reviews, from the 1996 volume and their listings. The comprehensive survey of recorded classical music is... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0140513817
• ISBN13: 9780140513813
• Release Date: January 1998
• Publisher: Puffin Books
• Length: 699 Pages
• Weight: 1.30 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.1" x 6.0" x 9.2"

Customer Reviews

Excellent but dated. Still valuable source espec. w/Gramopho

The Penguin Guide to Compact Discs is a superb guide. There are many explanatory reviews. This edition is dated vs. the later Bargain CDs and 1999 versions. The Penguin Guides lack indexes to composers, works, conductors and performers. On the other hand and in contrast to Gramophone Guides, Penguin rates each CD reviewed. Gramophone has the indexes but then takes one CD or maybe two from each work and reviews it. But then other versions are listed, some with stars indicating higherdesirability. Penguin rates each version (CD) reviewed and provides reasoning for rating some better than others. I really rate this 4 1/2*. With indexes, this would get 5* and a Rosette. The sensitive music lover will have a current copy of Penguin and Gramophone guides, along perhaps with one smaller book that lists a few recommended works for certain popular classical works.I have three copies of Penguin guides. I often take one into Barnes and Noble to check while looking at CDs. I use both Penguin and Gramophone in reviewing CDs on auction or for sale. One major problem is that Gramophone and Penguin tend to pick a different version of each work as best. So, which is? There isn't too much agreement. This is an advantage for the person who has the time or inclination to experiment. Another problem is some of the more current composers, especially in the 20th century are overlooked. These problems are insignificant. If I see a new work, thereis the gut. Also, some CD houses will permit returning versions that aren't as expected.This is a MUST. Look for the Bargain CD guide and also the latter version though. Gramophone is also a must, especially the 1999 edition.

Useful and comprehensive

Busloads of classical CDs have been issued - some would say dumped - on the market in the last decade. No one publication can assess them all, but these writers, all contributors to Gramophone, Britain's oldest magazine about classical recorded music, have a better hope than most. They are particularly good at pointing out interesting, underpublicised reissues or bargain releases that the conventional press have overlooked. They are less good on releases from really small companies, or those aimed at non-English speaking markets. Their overview is careful and a bit too conservative: if a performance is eccentric but inspired, they will sooner dismiss it as eccentric than praise it as exciting. But you will soon get used to their critical stance, accommodate it and learn to read between the lines. As a source of information about new CDs this guide is easy to use and hard to better. Richard Bernas,