The Loch Ness Story

By Nicholas Witchell

Book Overview

No Synopsis Available.

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0140041540
• ISBN13: 9780140041545
• Release Date: January 1976
• Publisher: Penguin Group
• Length: 155 Pages
• Weight: 0.30 lbs.

Customer Reviews

SHY MONSTER

Q: What's the difference between the Loch Ness monster and weapons of mass destruction in Iraq? A: They're still looking for the Loch Ness monster. The whole saga dates basically from 1933, when the most famous photograph, apparently showing the head and neck of the alleged beast, was taken by one Colonel Wilson. Sightings, dim photographs and echo-soundings have continued ever since, but the story still has the status of myth rather than anything else in both the popular and the scientific view. Loch Ness is the largest and deepest of a chain of ribbon lochs, connected by the Caledonian Canal, stretching along the geological fault-line between Inverness and the Atlantic across the width of the Scottish highlands. At its deepest it may be a full 1000 feet, and its lower regions are almost impenetrably murky owing to saturation of the water with particles of peat. Nicholas Witchell is a BBC journalist who has taken an interest in the issue from his teens, and his book is an admirably thorough, balanced and honest account of the history of the investigations from 1933 to at least 1989, the date of my edition. Is there or isn't there some colony of strange creatures down there? It really comes down to who and what we are prepared to believe. If they exist, the creatures are shy of human beings. They appear to be frightened off by noise, for instance, and of course the area has great attractions for tourists as well as investigators. However if they do exist, it seems certain that they have to come up for air at times. Reports indicate beasts of up to 30' in length, which I gather is over the maximum theoretical size for anything that can breathe with gills. Witchell assembles the evidence with great thoroughness. Hoaxes there have been, and in particular one exceptionally determined investigation in 1975 seems to have made an honest but serious mistake that did nothing to assuage scepticism. Sightings are reported by people that one would not normally think of as over-impressionable or over-bibulous, such as a local headmistress and a Benedictine monk from the abbey at Fort Augustus at the western end of the loch. Even if we discount the majority of reports as intrinsically untrustworthy, to reject them all involves the belief that a very large number of independent reports by pillars of the community are either deluded or mendacious. Witchell discusses, as of course he must, the attitudes among the scientific community, and he makes an important and valid point. This is that scientists are terrified of unorthodoxy, fearful for their reputations and of their colleagues who will crucify them unmercifully if they associate themselves with any point of view lacking the imprimatur of the scientific thought-police. How well founded this anxiety is can be seen from the way an established and reputable zoologist, Denys W Tucker, was treated for so much as declaring an open mind on the issue. What is also quite indisputably true is that scientific sce

Excellently researched, quality read.

Without doubt, this book has to be one of the best researched and published volumes on the case of the Loch Ness Monster. Witchell utilises his physical knowledge of the loch, gained through his years with a leading Loch Ness research group of the 1960's. New evidence is covered as is the history of the area, its people and the environment. In recent weeks it has, in some quarters been classed as the 'definitive guide' to all matters Loch Ness. Whilst i do not agree with that opinion, I would categorise it as one of the best books ever published upon the subject, and very much a valuable addition to any Loch Ness Monster library collection.