Von Steinberg's methodical investigation uncovers the gang's base, recovers bodies from a cave burial chamber, and discovers journals documenting their crimes with business-like precision. After a raid kills two gang members, four survivors are captured, including Bingelhelm. Through interrogation under torture (legally sanctioned but morally troubling), comprehensive confessions are obtained.
The trial results in extraordinary punishments: Bingelhelm is quartered after preliminary torture with red-hot pincers, in a spectacular public execution witnessed by thousands. His remains are scattered across the territory as warning. The prosecution extends to merchants and corrupt officials who enabled the gang.
Years later, von Steinberg reflects on the case's moral complexities: justice was served but couldn't restore victims; torture obtained confessions of uncertain reliability; the spectacular execution may have normalized excessive violence. The case became legend, transforming documented history into cautionary myth about evil's nature and law's necessary but imperfect response