Sleuthing C.S. Lewis

by Kathryn Lindskoog

Book Overview

Sleuthing C. S. Lewis is the latest installment in the story of the most bizarre literary and religious scandal of the late twentieth century. Within a few months of C. S. Lewis's death in 1963,... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0865547300
• ISBN13: 9780865547308
• Release Date: August 2001
• Publisher: Mercer University Press
• Length: 436 Pages
• Weight: 1.45 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.3" x 6.1" x 9.1"

Customer Reviews

We're Not in Narnia Anymore, Mr. Tumnus.

Dr. Kathryn Lindskoog's latest book on what she refers to as "the C. S. Lewis Hoax," is one that readers of her other two books on the subject will not want to miss.I read and very much enjoyed her early study of the theology of the Narnia books, "The Lion of Judah in Never-Never Land." Her first of three books on the hoax, "The C. S. Lewis Hoax," published in 1988, read like a mystery thriller and had me hooked from page one. I was thrilled at her dective skills, horrified that so many people had been duped by the Lewis Estate, and amused at her contention that Lewis himself, while objecting to his published work being tampered with, would, at the same time, probably enjoy a good chuckle over the whole thing. My initial skepticism was quashed by the extensive documentation provided in the book, as well as the positive support from C. S. Lewis friends and authorities she received in response to the book.If even half of the extensively documented, footnoted allegations and questions Lindskoog raises in this latest book are true, the C. S. Lewis Estate, and Wallter Hooper in particular, have some serious explaining to do. To date, no answers, only threats of lawsuits have been forthcoming from Hooper and Co.As if they needed it, Lindskoog's allegations are lent even more credibility by the fact that several prominent C. S. Lewis scholars, authors and academics, such as Lloyd Alexander, Arthur C. Clarke, Algis Budrys, Gene Wolfe, Joe Christopher and Lyle Dorset, have signed petitions (reprinted in the book's appendix section) asking Hooper and the Lewis estate to provide answers to Lindskoog's charges that "The Dark Tower" and other recently piublished Lewis material are forgeries written by Hooper, a former Episcopalian clergyman from Kentucky, who now affects a British accent and Lewisian mannerisms, and that portions of modern reprints of other Lewis works, such as "Screwtape Letters," have been altered by Hooper. The answers they provide are crucial for a true and accurate understanding of the Lewis corpus; if it's been tampred with, we need to know! Walter Hooper is routinely touted as the "foremost authority on C. S. Lewis," a position he seems unwilling to downplay; this is incorrect-for, as her works demonstrate, Kathryn Lindskoog is the foremost authority on C. S. Lewis.If you're at all interested in Lewis, or Lewis studies, I urge you to get this book! (and the other two) Then write a letter to the Lewis Estate demanding they put forward answers.Thank you Dr. Lindskoog, for providing us with more light in the Shadowlands.

A real find

Kathryn Lindskoog does not appear to take the role of judge or prosecuting attorney, but of investigative journalist as well as literary critic. She makes it clear in the preface material that this is an updated, expanded version of her earlier book "Light in the Shadowlands (also an excellent read). The interesting subtitle here is MORE Light in the Shadowlands. Anyone who dislikes wit and cheerful satire in serious scholarship should not read Lindskoog, because that's what she's noted for. One should note that there is some extremely important new material in "Sleuthing", such as proof that 45 of the 75 poems that Lewis published in his lifetime were altered in 1964 by someone named Walter Hooper. So the versions that are familiar to Lewis' readers are inferior to what Lewis actually wrote. (One becomes increasingly familiar with Hooper in both books). Some of the poems are completely ruined. She also reveals shocking new facts about the secret ownership of the Lewis literary estate and the fact that the royalties on his estate go to (get this) a tax shelter in Lichtenstein, where they can't be investigated.There are plenty of other new suprises in this highly entertaining new book, and I highly recommend it!

essential reading

Lindskoog leaves a comet-trail of controversy wherever she goes in Lewis studies, but nobody who is interested in the writings of C. S. Lewis can afford to be ignorant of the case she makes in this book and in its earlier version, _Light in the Shadowlands_. What, after all, _are_ the writings of C. S. Lewis? There appears to be legitimate doubt about the authorship of some of the posthumously-released material._Sleuthing C. S. Lewis_ is an update and expansion of Lindskoog's earlier volume, and the text contains numerous additions. I thought it well worth the read, both to revisit the old material and to pick out the new. Also, this version has a much-needed index, unlike the earlier edition.The text is marred by an unusually large number of typographical errors, no doubt the result of being handled by a small university press. However, this book is an important one. It is civil yet witty in tone and packed with fascinating stuff. Buy, read, make up your own mind. (Or reserve judgement until more complete evidence is available, as the case may be.) These are important questions, and Lindskoog is the only writer on the market that treats them.