Over five decades, she has crafted visionary work that has reinvigorated poetry's power to awaken the reader. Her groundbreaking poems have been testimonies, enquiries and wonderments. They daringly map a territory where poetry asserts our inexhaustible responsibility to each other. Her meditative poetry has a majestic sweep, with themes ranging from life on earth and human existence to history, war, genocide and the Holocaust. Her retrospective, Otherwhere, is published fifty years after her debut, Gathering the Tribes, winner of the Yale Series of Younger Poets Award in 1975. It includes selections from that book and from four subsequent collections published by Bloodaxe in the UK: The Country Between Us (1981/2019), The Angel of History (1994), Blue Hour (2003) and In the Lateness of the World (2021), and opens with If there is ink, a group of 16 new poems. After publishing her first collection with Yale in the US, she had three collections from Ecco and one from Penguin, with Otherwhere having simultaneous US and UK publication by Scribner and Bloodaxe.
According to Joyce Carol Oates (New York Times Book Review), Forch 's ability to wed the "political" with the "personal" places her in the company of such poets as Pablo Neruda, Philip Levine and Denise Levertov. Jane Miller called Blue Hour "a masterwork for the 21st century". Carolyn Forch 's own selection from her books is prefaced with an introductory essay, "Older Than Glass, Younger Than Music: a poetics", in which she relates her life and times to her development as a poet and thinker, tracing the shifts in her poetry across her five collections.