Old Mother Hubbard (The Best book club ever)

By Sarah Catherine Martin

Book Overview

Caldecott Honor winner James Marshall tops himself Old Mother Hubbard Went to the Cupboard, To fetch her poor dog a bone; But when she came there The cupboard was bare And so the poor dog had none.... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Loose Leaf
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0394834763
• ISBN13: 9780394834764
• Release Date: January 1977
• Publisher: Random House Books
• Length: 32 Pages
• Weight: 0.22 lbs.

Customer Reviews

silly silliness

I'm not sure the original had as many verses as this- but the number makes for a good bout of goofiness and lots of fun illustrations. We start out with the bare cupboards- bare because the mice had dined in the pantry, complete with a waiter, and the dead dog. Poor Mother Hubbard tries to do right by her dog by immediately dressing in black and buying a coffin, but the darned dog had tricked her and wasn't dead after all! phew! Instead, Mother Hubbard goes shopping everywhere for her dear dog- to the barber, the the tailor, the cobbler, the fruit stand, the tavern- but always, when she returns home, the dog is doing something else and doesn't need coffin, the coat, the shoes, the fruit, the wine. But we do get to see the silliness of the various shop owners and Mother Hubbard in an amazing amount of finery including a fantastic cowgirl outfit all "little old ladies" should consider wearing. At least now and then.

A neater version of the classic poem

This is one interesting version of the classic poem, "Old Mother Hubbard." One interesting detail for the verse, "But when she came back the poor dog was dead" is that the picture shows that the dog wrote a note saying he couldn't live without a bone. An interesting comment on the picture for the undertaker verse is that the coffin is shown wrapped up like a present. In fact, it looks to me like a gift box of chocolates. James Marshall has extended the classic poem to include his own verses(well, it is an easy poem for which to make up your own verses).

Great oldie redone

A classic childrens tale redone into a great piece ofliterature for any young child! Great pictures! END