Mary Neilson knows all about harmony as a professional matchmaker and a chronic people pleaser, so she never meant to clash with public radio news show host Ruben Byers during an on-air interview. Their tense exchange on the state of modern dating generates buzz for the show. As a result, Ruben's boss tasks him with producing a feature exploring the subject, where, for research, he must join Hearts Collide Matchmaking as one of Mary's clients.
It's an arrangement neither of them wants, but to improve her chances of a promotion, Mary accepts the challenge of finding the vexing but handsome radio host a match. Ruben's commitment to his work drives him to keep his doubts about the process and his unexpected attraction to Mary at bay.