Germaine Greer, Untamed Shrew

by Christine Wallace

Book Overview

Germaine Greer is one of the opinion-formers of our age, her challenging views constantly provoking us in print and on the small screen. The Female Eunuch, her first book published in 1970, was hailed... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0571199348
• ISBN13: 9780571199341
• Release Date: January 1998
• Publisher: Faber & Faber
• Length: 360 Pages
• Weight: 1.59 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.3" x 6.4" x 9.3"

Customer Reviews

A book that suits its subject

Ever since a delusional friend told me that I would be very impressed by The Female Eunuch, I have wondered why Greer seems to attract so much admiration. I read most of her books, attempting to discover the attraction. (I gave up after the dreadful Daddy We Hardly Knew Ye.) I would suggest that the reader who wants to see her at her best read the appropriately named The Mad Woman's Underclothes. Her earlier essays are witty, incisive and clever. The quality does deteriorate as the book goes on, but at least I had some insight into what people admire. I read this biography hoping to understand Greer's admirers; I still don't but perhaps that isn't Wallace's fault. It is always difficult to ascertain how accurate biographical material is unless there is a lot of it to be compared. Therefore, I cannot say if Christine Wallace is accurate and insightful, but I will say that my readings of Greer's works make this biography very plausible. I was actually a trifle surprised that other reviewers described Wallace as hostile: I thought she was kinder than Greer deserved. Sometimes when a subject comes across poorly, it is because of their own flaws, not the biographer's. Wallace actually admired a number of things about Greer: she thinks that The Female Eunuch was a powerful book, even if she did think that Greer was cashing in on the times. She admires her defiance of convention in her college days, remarks on her intelligence, her creativity and her talent for acting. As for the charges that Greer is hypocritical, inconsistent, and tells wildly variant versions of her life, I can only suggest that the reader consult Greer's own work. Her thought is rather warped by mother-blaming and the conviction that in any society other than what I'll call Western-Industrial, all children are loved and well treated. How bad a mother was Mrs. Greer? Extremely abusive and probably mental ill, according to her daughter's writings, but Wallace says that Greer now denies that she was abused. Greer wants women in the Western-Industrial cultures to make a spectacle, particularly a sexual spectacle of themselves, while admiring the modesty of traditional cultures. Greer is the woman, who in The Female Eunuch, so admired close-knit Italian family life that she wanted to buy a farm and leave her child(ren) to be raised in Italy by her tenants, while she continued to live her sophisticated life in England. (She has denied this, but I read the book.) She doesn't seem to care to live by her own convictions, or I suppose that she would be living in an arranged marriage in her beloved India. She wondered, I believe it was in Daddy, We Hardly Knew You, why Australians thought that she doesn't like them. My guess would be that they read her earlier books. A case can be made for many of the points that Greer raises, but taken altogether she is incoherent. I don't sympathize with Greer's claims that this book has invaded her privacy. Even a public p