Abigail's college life is going great, excelling in her degree path, when she meets a guy named Joey at a college party, who just so happens to live not too far away from her in her hometown. She's reluctant to settle down with him because she likes to have different options, which ultimately leads to her attraction to the off-limits man: Joey's father, Nick.
During her winter break home from college, Abigail finds herself growing in attraction to Nick each day. She is stuck deciding whether to choose her first interest, Joey, or his attractive father. Which path will she ultimately choose?