In the late 19th century, a plague nearly destroys the small Midwestern town of Black Creek. Believing that the sickness is a punishment by God for their sins, the local preacher begins sacrificing the town's citizens to the creek itself. Today, the town has changed its name and all but forgotten the curse that was placed upon the river. Sugar Grove is nothing like its predecessor. Life is peaceful and prosperous. The people of Sugar Grove are happy. Children can be heard laughing with joy. Nothing bad ever happens in Sugar Grove. That is, until the day a young boy does the unthinkable and awakens the curse. And like before, townsfolk become sick with an illness the doctors cannot explain. The people of Sugar Grove are left helpless by an enormous storm that leaves them without power for days. From out of the storm walks a stranger, soaking wet from the storm and barefoot. The meaning of the stranger's appearance is unknown, but as people begin to die, Aaron Pike, a newly appointed sheriff, and Jillian Harper, a high school English teacher, race against time to uncover the secret of the curse before the entire town is destroyed.