Caroline Hirsch's husband Hunter died five years ago. So this new guy in town can't be him. He just can't be. So why do they look exactly alike? Is Caroline's long-dead husband really coming back from beyond the grave?
She had to rebuild her life after Hunter died and she did that by having the child she always wanted. So what if she used donor sperm to get pregnant? Now she's the mother of a beautiful little boy and she's a great mom. She has nothing to be ashamed of. Even if Hunter came back-which he wouldn't-he would be proud of her. She has no reason to think he would mind that she has a son now. Right?
It isn't him, though. Noah Goldsmith is a completely different guy and every inch as magnetic, handsome, and unstoppable as Hunter ever was-maybe more so. Now Noah is throwing Caroline's whole world into turmoil by asking her out and.....everything else. The two can't get enough of each other and he doesn't seem to mind that she's going out with him because he looks identical to her dead husband. Is she going out with him because he looks identical to her dead husband? Caroline can't tell anymore.
Just when she thinks this situation can't get any more surreal, her past catches up with the present in the most disastrous possible way. She can only hope they're all still standing when the dust clears.