Elderly Amish widows, Ettie and her sister, Elsa-May, settle down for a comfortable Christmas night not knowing they're in for a surprise. One by one guests arrive claiming they've been invited to a 'Christmas dinner they'll never forget.' Among the guests are Ettie's estranged daughter, Myra, and the retired Detective Crowley. When a man is found dead in the widows' front yard, Crowley immediately takes over and determines that the man has been murdered...