Customer Reviews of The Dante Club
Dante, Longfellow, and Lowell, Together Again
It wasn't really necessary to read Longfellow's recently re-released translation of Dante's Inferno - but I did it anyway before starting on The Dante Club. Even without the homework which proved not to be at all necessary, this new novel is a captivating, page-turner that draws you in and holds your attention. Meticulously researched, but brilliantly crafted, readers will be brought back to post-Civil War Cambridge and Boston and experience life as the great authors and publishers and common people and low lives might have done.
Historically accurate (from my perspective as a lifelong Cambridge MA history buff) and with characters true to whom they were, the novel was entertaining, stimulating, and informative. And Pearl keeps working for us until the end.
If you've ever visited Boston and Cambridge, you'll enjoy walking in the paths Longfellow, James Russell Lowell, Oliver Wendell Holmes, and the great publishers of the era - all of whom play significant roles in the story.
I'm looking forward to the next book.
Para ser la primera novela de este joven autor, El Club Dante es un triller entretenido que mantiene al lector en suspenso de principio a fin. Excelente su estilo narrativo con detalles explicitos que nos transporta a los mas bajos pecados del Boston del Siglo 19...
Excellent Historical Recreation
This novel is a must read for those of us who love literature and the art of literary translation. I admit that I have read only a little over half the novel, not because I find it boring; quite the opposite: I find it too wonderful to want to finish it in haste. Slowly, slowly I read with exquisite pleasure -- quite the opposite of those in Dante's hell who suffer exquisitely forever -- or at least a long time.
The novel is set in post Civil War Boston. Longfellow, Holmes, Lowell and their publisher are the "private" detectives as well as the most prominent members of the Dante Club, a club dedicated to translating Dante into English. In a kind of Borgesian world where fact and fiction overlap, the detectives are challenged by a serial murderer who has decided to translate Dante's Inferno into a horrific reality.
Who is this murderer and how far will he succeed in translating Boston into Dante's inferno? You and I will have to continue reading to find out.
There are not enough mysteries with a real literary component. Matthew Pearl provides us one and we should be grateful. There are many enjoyable mysteries, but to read one that has both historical and literary ingredients is a real find. The Dante Club provides all of that and an interesting mystery as well.
I rate it right along side such other historical and literary mysteries as The Name of the Rose and The Alienist.
Wonderful historical mystery/thriller !
I don't usually read mysteries, but since this book has a historical setting, which I love, I gave it a try. I loved this book! The concept is so imaginative and it made me look deeper into the actual writings of Dante and the American poets -- works I hadn't thought about since College Prep. English in high school. I will buy Matthew Pearl's next book. But one note: another reviewer was outraged by the "antagonistic" foreward in this book. I presumed the foreward to be just more fiction, created by the author, and found it compelling.