It's Not about the Truth: The Untold Story of the Duke Lacrosse Case and the Lives It Shattered

by Don Yaeger

Book Overview

Mike Pressler walked into the bottom-floor meeting room of the Murray Building and, as he had done hundreds of times over a sixteen-year career at Duke University, prepared to address his men's lacrosse team. Forty-six players sat in theater-style chairs, all eyes riveted forward.It was 4:30 P.M. on Wednesday, April 5, 2006. The program's darkest hour had arrived in an unexpected and explosive announcement.Pressler, a three-time ACC Coach of the Year,...

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 1416551468
• ISBN13: 9781416551461
• Release Date: June 2007
• Publisher: Threshold Editions
• Length: 321 Pages
• Weight: 1.20 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.2" x 6.5" x 9.3"

Customer Reviews

Count to Ten Before You...

Don Yaeger did an excellent job researching the Duke Case and exposing the fraud. Sadly, neither of the black strippers have been held accountable for their actions. Sexual abuse--seems to be the new "Witch Hunt" in America where just being accused destroys one's life and the accusers go unpunished when they have been proven liars. Worse yet--were the 88 professors who broke every rule of a liberal by not only prejudging the three young men--but putting it in writing. I cannot see how Duke can keep that group employed. How can they TEACH impartially after having played their cards so openly prejudiced? Well done Yaeger!

Excellent Book About Shocking Injustice

Just when you thought that you knew everything about the Duke University Lacrosse Rape Case, here comes a new book that shows just how little you really knew about it all. There are several things about the case that did not make the headlines but which explains just what a shocking case of injustice this really was. *The book explains why the man who the Duke Lacrosse team resent most is not District Attorney Nifong, but instead university President Brodhead. *The book shows how a black student named Nartey sent threatening emails to team coach Pressler and not only was never punished for it, but was actually rewarded with a seat on a prestigious committee. Meanwhile, a white student named McFadyen sent some joke emails about to case to a private group of friends and wound up being suspended from the university. In other words, different strokes for different folks. *The book exposes the shameful practices of the Durham Police Department. *The book exposes the shameful conduct of a group of college professors known as the "Group of 88" who went out of their way to inflame the situation and make wildly false accusations against the Lacrosse team members. An added bonus to this book is an open letter by Coach Mike Pressler's 15 year old daughter Janet addressed to university president Brodhead that is a stunning indictment of Brodhead's conduct during the case. If there is any book that you absolutely, positively have to read this year, then this is the one.

A must read for those interested in this amazing story

I was half expecting to read very familiar stuff when I got this book. I was amazed at how much new material this book presented and how much I could not put it down. This is a wonderfully written book that stays with you long after you read it. Just be prepared to be glued to the pages from the moment you open this new classic of judicial literature. Coach Pressler's descriptions of this event recalls the Salem Witch trials. It is amazing something like this could happen nowadays and the fact we all lived through it makes it even more interesting. This is written in such a personal and fluid style that time just ceases to exist when you open this book. There is so much details that will leave you shocked that you really feel as if you are living the case and also feel joy at how justice was eventually done. Sadly, Coach Pressler lost his job but history will recall him as a wonderful coach and person while others such as the Duke administrators (including the Duke President)and Durham Legal and Police depts will be forever linked with a despicable period in legal history. Long after we are all gone their names will still live in infamy. It they have a conscience they would feel shamed. I recommend as highly as I have ever recommended a book.

Powerful

"It's Not About the Truth" by the former head coach of the Duke lacrosse team, Mike Pressler, is an engrossing and enlightening read. I thought that I had paid attention throughout the process, and still learned a great deal and picked up some keen insights. The book chronicles the events from the phone call to escort service up to declaration of "innocent" and the start of the 2007 lacrosse season. Major and bit players in the drama are profiled and their actions recounted in a documentary/narrative style that is easy to follow and comprehend. The University bureaucrats (starting with President Brodhead) showed no profiles in courage and abandoned the team, its season and Coach Pressler in a show of politically correct CYA. The AD is revealed as a cowardly marionette whose word was not his bond. The 88 faculty members (20% of the Duke staff) who took out a full-page "social disaster" ad in the student newspaper openly flew their agenda flag. A huge rush to judgment before the facts were known. As egregiously as the university acted in forsaking the team and coach, the actions of the DA (Mike Nifong) and the Durham PD were enough to prompt two ethics charges from the North Carolina State Bar. Trial starts this week. Nifong's rush to judgment was motivated by his desire to be elected in the 2006 DA race. The book points out that he never spoke to the escort (complainant) until about eight months after the supposed incident. The book does show where the profiles in courage reside. Ironically, it is James Ammons (Chancellor at the historically black college NCCU), who was the initial public voice of reason...being the first to say "don't rush to judgment." Coach Pressler and his family proved to be a rock of stability in all the turmoil for the team. After speaking with the Senior Captains, he knew they were speaking the truth...and never wavered in this belief. While the AD was not supportive, the other coaches were loyal to the lacrosse team. The legal team was incredible. Joseph Chesire V said he knew after three minutes that Dave Evans was telling the truth, and proceeded accordingly. The members of the team and their parents are the real heroes. The anguish and anxiety they all suffered waiting for the third indictment had to be excruciating. Lives were turned upside down for over a year. They banded together and never lost faith in one another. That not one underclassman transferred showed a great leap of faith to a university that did not show the same loyalty. It took a lot of bravery, trust and faith for the parents to send their sons back to Duke. "The Truth" kept their resolve intact. Anyone who saw the address Dave Evans gave on May 15, 2006 knew he was speaking from the heart and meant every word he said. It was a powerful moment. If you watched him speak and did not know he was truthful you should not play poker, as every tell was there. There are some of us who never vacillated in believing in the innocence of

An Old Story Magnified

Books about contemporary events can be potboilers. It's Not About the Truth is absolutely not in that category! Author Don Yaeger has formidable credentials. He is a former associate editor of Sports Illustrated, the author of seven books, co-author of the New York Times bestseller, Under the Tarnished Dome, and the critically acclaimed Pros and Cons: The Criminals Who Play in the NFL. His honesty, expertise, skills, and perception are highly significant in a crisis in which those attributes have been and are so often missing. Yaeger's style is clear, revealing in both detail and perspective, consistently lively, producing a story hard to put down. He states his opinions as well as rendering them through detailed reporting, a considerable amount either missed or not available before even in Durham. The very extensive interviews from many differing angles and his work with Coach Mike Pressler are especially valuable, often strikingly to the point. Coach Pressler kept a diary from the first days of the drama. These sources are very extensive, exciting to read, and illuminate the events from innumerable directions, often of strategic value. The Duke Lacrosse Case, although a media phenomenon, is by no means a new aspect of institutional life, here and elsewhere, whatever the endeavor. This story shines another powerful beam upon management style and mentality, and how some, far too many, regard the groups and individuals subject to their power. A foxhole attitude, refusal to acknowledge mistakes, and a callous disregard for individuals and groups, however valuable their contributions have been and could be, are widespread. Here one thinks of Lee Iacocca's Where Have All the Leaders Gone? This corrosive situation is exactly why the media and the whistleblowers are so necessary. How else would we know? Messrs. Yaeger and Pressler deserve our esteem and congratulations. Coach Pressler, the Duke Lacrosse Team, and their families and lawyers are class acts.